I'm sad to say the Babe has relapsed into his binky addiction again.
He was very much a binky baby. When he was fairly little, we restricted the binky usage to bedtime only. We didn't want him to be one of those kindergarteners who takes their binky to school the first day.
After a while, we tried taking the binky away during bedtime. It was hard! He'd find an old binky here or there. He'd hide it. If he didn't find one, he'd cry at night till I'd finally give in.
Finally, I cut the rubber part of the binky off so he could hold the binky but there wasn't a sucking part. He did realize it was "broken" and we'd throw it away every night. Then after he was asleep, I'd get it back out of the trash and put it away from the next day he'd ask for it. He finally stopped asking for it.
After the Little Lady was born, it became clear that he wanted her binky now and when we got the Little Foster Man, it got worse!
We've tried to address it and be firm with a no-binky policy. That didn't work. Now we're trying a let him have it approach in hopes he'd lose interest. It's not working and the bad part about it is he's got a little rash under his lip from sucking the binky all day.
There are lots of binky lying around our house with 2 little babies.
We don't know what to do now. Any suggestions?